At book events, I’m often asked how I came up with my book’s title, Jumping Over Shadows (see that story here: How to Come Up with a Book Title). Recently, however, when I told the story of the title, someone asked what the other contending titles had been. I thought this would make an interesting book companion post.

An Impossible Love, Revisited

This was my working title. A friend and I came up with it after she’d read one of my very first drafts. We met up at a writing conference and brainstormed for a long time. We liked this one because it spoke to the central love story, and it also captured the curious coincidence of the same impossible love happening twice in my family. The back and forth between the story of the past and the story of the present is the basic structure of the book, and also, according to one reader, one of the main sources of its tension. I also liked this title’s echo of Brideshead Revisited.

The Benefit of Secrets

This was the other finalist title. My book title focus group argued back and forth between it and “Jumping Over Shadows.” Unlike the latter, it’s a concept title, i.e. not based on a quote from the book. I came up with it as I reviewed the title ideas the copy editor had sent me. I liked “The Benefit of Secrets” because it expresses something contradictory to current popular psychology, when airing secrets is always seen as a good thing and keeping them is always a bad thing. More than one secret is kept in my book. In fact, one of them is kept for lifetimes, not resolved at the end and probably saved several lives (I also get asked about that quite often but I won’t spill the beans here.).

I am very happy with the book’s title but it’s still nice to remember what else it could have been, and also to pay some homage to the long road of coming up with it. If you’ve read Jumping Over Shadows, I’d love to hear what you think of these other titles. Would they have done the book justice?